Nothing is black and white. Everything is black and white. As I write this I’m not sure it will ever see the light of day. I have spent the weekend so troubled that I haven’t been able to move. That’s figurative, of course, but I have found myself sitting in front of my Facebook feed alternatively crying, angry, and just plain despairing. I hope that by writing some of this down I can find some clarity, create some order out of events that make no sense and have no order.
The events of the past few days, weeks, months are horrible and terrifying. I wish I was a more eloquent writer so that I could capture the emotions that I feel. My heart breaks for the families of Alton Sterling and Philando Castile and others who have tragically been killed at the hands of police, as well as for those of the officers who were horrifically gunned down in Dallas.
What has left me frozen has been the divisiveness on social media in general and on my Facebook feed in particular. People I call friends (though I know on Facebook that doesn’t really mean a lot) choosing sides, calling names, passing judgement. To many of them, everything is black and white. No shades of gray.
While as a white woman I can never begin to understand what it is like to be a black person in this country, I can understand and empathize with anger and loss. I can see the racism in statements like, “well they shouldn’t resist,” or “if you break the law you get what you ask for.” As if the penalty for resisting or selling a few CDs should be death. As if an African American man should have to be a “good little black man” so that he doesn’t get killed!
Yes, I support the police. I have friends who are police officers. They put their lives on the line every moment of every day. Most are honorable men and women who live with the possibility of their own death all the time. But that doesn’t mean there aren’t bad cops out there. And to say otherwise is to totally depart from reality.
Remember that old statement, “America, love it or leave it”? When people said that, they were telling protestors that they should shut up and leave if they weren’t happy with things the way they were. But how do things get better if we don’t try to change them? I love my country, even if I disagree with some of what goes on. I honor and respect police officers while still wanting to weed out the bad ones.
If you’ve been paying attention at all this week, you’ve seen people saying, with emphasis, “all lives matter.” Of course, this is in response to the Black Lives Matter movement. Apparently, some people believe that by saying black lives matter, we are saying that no other lives matter. Not true. If you say, about your oldest child, “I love my oldest son,” does that mean you don’t love the others?
Of course, all lives matter! Whatever color, race, gender, sexual orientation, all lives have meaning and importance. But think about it. In the light of so many senseless deaths of black men and the reaction of so many of the people who blame them for their own deaths, in the face of prejudice and fear, can you not understand that it is important to remember that black lives matter too?
I don’t usually engage with people with whom I disagree on Facebook (or anywhere else, really). It’s not my style. I was compelled once or twice over the weekend to add my two cents simply because I felt I couldn’t keep quiet. That is why I (think) I’ll be publishing this. The time to be quiet is over. While I don’t think that arguing on Facebook will make any changes, speaking out, trying to clarify, making people think, just might. At least I hope so.
Katie Jenkins
Brilliantly written, Debbie. Compassionate, sincere, and brimming with grace. It was beautiful.🌷
Gilly Maddison
Yes I agree – very well expressed. I made the exact same point today while commenting on a blog post, about adding the word ‘too’ onto the ‘Black Lives matter’ slogan.
Such sad, mixed up world we live in. And regarding you sitting in front of your computer with all those emotions going on – I think lots of us are having the same experience. I have avoided TV news and newspaper for several years but since joining FB, I have found that really negative downside where bad news is thrust in your face before you can turn away.
It isn’t that I don’t care, it’s just that makes me feel physically ill when I see people hurting each other and as there is nothing we can do about it, the horror of other peoples’ lives just comes down to a form of bizarre entertainment. A very good post – thank you.
Marsha
Well written. I had a friend who is a pastor write this, and I must agree: “When Black people, White people, Hispanic people, Asian people begin to DEMAND better from their own community, then we will truly be able to come together. ” It singles out no one and yet everyone in that it puts the responsibility back on each one to look in the mirror and at his or her own community and what we can do to begin the change in our own hearts and own communities, families, etc. Tough times we live in.
Laura
Yes to all of this. I’m so incredibly disturbed and sad and angry… I don’t even know what to say anymore.
I chocked at the All Star game last night when the Canadian guy singing his anthem held up an All Loves Matter sign and chanhed the words to his own anthem. What was he thinking?!
Very well-written. And I agree on the posting… It’s important to get people to think and have a discussion. You know, handle things like adults.
Darrell Harris
Hello Debbie:
Great post! Your article really lays out some of the challenges here. Black and white was very touching and moving.Those are some really great points and thanks for sharing them. I agree with you 100% we have to sit down and have conversation and relevant discussions,because all this senseless violence ,gets the “real” hate mongers charged up. As a black man I know ,black lives matter people and I have friends who are police officers and I’m aware 99% are great people. Super post and have a great day. Keep sharing.